Healthy Halloween Candy

With Halloween coming up, we’re sure you’re getting ready for those trick-or-treaters to come through, holding their baskets out for that sweet stuff. It can be hard to resist when you’re constantly surrounded by it! But if you’re following a particular diet or just trying to stay away from those seriously scary ingredients that can be found in some candies (truly, you don’t even need to watch a horror film this season, just look at the back of a wrapper instead), it can be frustrating! 

So we’ve rounded up 15 of our favorite homemade healthier Halloween treats to satisfy your cravings this holiday season without having you feeling left out or like you need to fall off the bandwagon! While some of these still contain some sugar so they should be enjoyed as a treat, it’s unprocessed sugar and a fraction of what you would find in real candy. 

Check out these spooky favorites that range from dairy-free, vegan, Paleo, refined sugar-free, soy-free, Keto, and more!

Healthier Butterfingers

Paleo Vegan Caramel Filled Chocolate Cups

4 Ingredient Pumpkin Fudge

Vegan Low Sugar Peanut Butter Buckeyes Swap out the peanut butter with almond butter to make it Paleo! 

Healthier Homemade Twix Bars

Cashew Butter Swirled Chocolate Bark

Vegan Homemade Snickers (make it Paleo by swapping in almonds for peanuts!)

Homemade Tootsie Rolls

Paleo Vegan Worms + Dirt Pudding A childhood classic, the gummy worms are completely Paleo, vegan, and made from veggie and fruit juices!

Homemade Peanut Butter M&M’s

Homemade Paleo Vegan Hershey’s Kisses Make the whole cookie or just the homemade Hershey’s kisses!

Paleo Vegan Cashew Caramel Clusters Swap in whichever nut butter you want! If you can’t do nuts, we recommend coconut butter or sunflower seed butter!

Keto Chocolate Coconut Cups

Paleo Vegan Coconut Cream Eggs omit the sweetener for another great Keto option!

Vegan Milkyway

Happy Halloween!